
For a while, whenever I was enthusiastic about a new album, it would always bum me out when I read reviews that didn’t feel the same way.
I’d immediately place some distance between myself and that record. After all, if a professional music reviewer couldn’t enjoy the object of my audible affection, what hope did I have? This got complicated when my job was to review music professionally.
It wasn’t so much that I thought the album I enjoyed was any worse than before. I just felt as though no matter what I told people, there wasn’t a consensus to back me up. I could evangelize a band’s work to someone, but eventually that person would go online and read a bunch of contrary opinions by others. (This is also known as the “Plight of the Insane Clown Posse Fan.”)
This kind of thing can certainly challenge credibility. But who’s cred is on the line if you’re just being honest?
The New Pornographers released an new album earlier this year called Together and it’s fucking great.
It’s a nice continuation from the band’s last album, 2007′s Challengers, which a sizable section of the group’s fanbase seemed to hate. Longtime fans of the New Pornographers had grown accustomed to the punchy power pop display on 2005′s Twin Cinema.
Not me. I didn’t care for Twin Cinema back in 2005 and I’ve only mildly let it into my heart since. It’s not a bad collection of songs, but the New Pornographers sound is different on that record.
Sometime between 2005 and 2007, the New Pornographers went from loud, propulsive, hyper-rock to a more mellow, folky, melodic sound accented by thick, rich harmonies.
The New Pornographers are led by principal songwriter A.C. Newman, the second most famous redhead in the band. Between 2005 and 2007, Newman fell in love and got married to Christy Simpson, who works at the band’s label, Matador Records.
Challengers is an unabashed, upbeat, warm, sweet, doe-eyed album about falling in love. The title track details a couple preparing to embark on a relationship they can’t control, against the odds. It’s a beautiful sentiment that echos throughout the 12 tracks.
If Simpson was the muse for Challengers, you can probably guess how the follow-up, Together, advances the narrative. Since Challengers was released, Newman and Simpson relocated from New York City to upstate NY. The first song on Together is called “Moves” and has a fading refrain of “you and I move” towards the conclusion. The closing track is titled “We End Up Together.” You see where this is headed.
Since getting into Challengers back in 2007, I’ve gone through the band’s back catalogue: 2000′s Mass Romantic, 2003′s Electric Version, and 2005′s Twin Cinema. For my money, Newman’s work with the New Pornographers has never sounded more focused or inspired as between 2007 and 2010.
Challengers and Together are two fully realized albums with equal parts weight and joy, and we probably have Christy Simpson to thank.
Yet both of these records received weak to tepid reactions from critics. I’m not sure if it was the group changing its vision or just a matter of taste, but that means people will be less inclined to give them a listen. And that’s probably the biggest bummer of all.
The New Pornographers are playing Oakland’s Fox Theatre tomorrow night. I’m going to be there, singing my face off, and I wish you were too.